Olive Ave Jewelry Logo
Product Education

Natural Diamonds: What Makes Them Unique, Rare, and Timeless

A clear guide to how natural diamonds are formed, what sets them apart, and how to choose one with confidence.

three natural diamond engagement ring close up.

Unique by nature or carefully made, every diamond carries character.

What Are Natural Diamonds?

Natural diamonds are formed deep within the Earth over billions of years, shaped by extreme heat and pressure. If you’ve ever wondered what are natural diamonds, the answer is simple: they’re gemstones created entirely by nature, long before they ever reach your hands. Each one is unique, making them some of the rarest and most meaningful gemstones in the world. 

Natural vs Lab Diamonds: What’s the Difference?

They tend to be more expensive than lab-created stones, which is why many couples compare natural vs lab diamonds when choosing a ring. The difference comes down to origin, rarity, and personal preference. Natural diamonds carry a long-standing cultural value that many people are drawn to. 

Understanding the Diamond Four Cs

While pricing can vary, it is largely influenced by what is known as the diamond Four Cs: cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. These qualities determine a diamond’s overall value and individuality, helping you understand what matters most when selecting a stone. 

Color, Composition, and Natural Beauty

Natural diamonds are made of pure carbon and pass a diamond tester. Although white [D-F] is the most traditional, they can also be found in shades like yellow, blue, and pink, also known as fancy, offering a range of options depending on your style. 

Natural Diamond Inclusions: What Makes Each Stone Unique

Because of the intense conditions during formation, natural diamond inclusions are common. These can appear as tiny crystals, bubbles, or soft hazy areas. They’re often described as nature’s fingerprints, giving each stone its own character. While some diamonds appear flawless under 10x magnification, every natural diamond has internal features when examined more closely. 

Durability and Everyday Wear

They rank 10 on the Mohs hardness scale, meaning they are among the hardest materials on Earth. Still, like any fine jewelry, they should be worn with care, as chipping or scratching can happen in certain conditions. All of our pieces are the highest quality and are made to last a lifetime with proper care.

How Olive Ave Selects Natural Diamonds

At Olive Ave, we partner with trusted suppliers to ensure every natural diamond we offer is conflict-free and responsibly sourced. We also hold our stones to high internal standards, offering diamonds that are I color or higher and SI2 clarity or better. Each stone is carefully selected to meet our Eye-Clean criteria, with many falling in the SI1 to VS2 range for a balance of beauty and value. 

Are Natural Diamonds Worth It?

So, are natural diamonds worth it? For many, the answer comes down to how much they value rarity, history, and individuality. There’s something meaningful about wearing a stone that formed over time, completely on its own. 

If you’re drawn to that sense of origin, along with timeless style and lasting significance, the natural diamond meaning may feel like the right fit for your story. 

Shop Rings

Larkin

$1,700

14K Yellow Gold

Ivy

$1,200
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Scottie

$1,600

14K Yellow Gold

Lowen

$965
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Elodie

$1,700

14K Yellow Gold

Knox

$1,165

14K Yellow Gold

Sybil

$970
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Vida

$1,260
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Bloom

$995
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Lou

$925
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Foster

$1,345

14K Yellow Gold

Wren

$1,100
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Grace

$950
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Essex

$2,100

14K Yellow Gold

Lady

$1,240

14K Yellow Gold

Ireland

$1,370

14K Yellow Gold

Ronan

$1,575

14K Yellow Gold

Lawson

$1,368

14K Yellow Gold

Rose

$1,480
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Darcy

$1,070

14K Yellow Gold

Rory

$1,060
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Elowen

$1,365

14K Yellow Gold

Carter

$850
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Eve

$1,540
Setting Only

14K Yellow Gold

Schedule an appointment with us to browse our collection of engagement rings, wedding bands, and more at our Arizona Showroom, Utah Showroom or virtually. Our team looks forward to helping you find your dream piece!


BOOK AN APPOINTMENT

Olive Ave Promise

Olive Ave Jewelry is the new face of a family-owned and operated jewelry company that has been in business for over 40 years, first established in 1981 as The Diamond Consortium.

Our focus is to bring the highest quality jewelry to our customers for the best price. We are happy to offer our curated selection, or help you customize the perfect piece for yourself or those you love.

Learn More